Casano's Pizza Parlor

Enjoy authentic, cozy pizza at Casano's Pizza Parlor in Rutherford, NJ. Offering delicious New Haven-style pies, chicken parm, and comfort food with dine-in, takeaway, or delivery. Family-friendly, casual atmosphere—perfect for dinner, solo dining, or catering.

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Casano's Pizza Parlor

Taste the Difference.

Casano's Pizza Parlor
Casano's Pizza Parlor
Casano's Pizza Parlor
Casano's Pizza Parlor

Nestled in the heart of Rutherford at 8 Highland Cross, Casano's Pizza Parlor invites you to experience classic New Jersey pizza with a nostalgic twist. This neighborhood gem blends timeless charm with culinary excellence, offering a cozy atmosphere that feels like grandma's living room—complete with vintage decor, a retro TV playing Donnie Brasco, and an old-school wooden phone booth. Whether you're seeking a quick, comforting bite or celebrating with family, Casano's delivers authentic pizza and hearty Italian fare. The staff's warm hospitality and community vibe turn every visit into a local celebration, making it your go-to spot for dinner or takeout. From the aroma of freshly baked crusts to the friendly banter at the counter, Casano's embodies the spirit of Rutherford’s vibrant local food scene.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

8 Highland Cross, Rutherford, NJ 07070, United States

Phone

None

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Casano's Pizza Parlor
Casano's Pizza Parlor
Casano's Pizza Parlor
Casano's Pizza Parlor

Casano's Pizza Parlor has served Rutherford since its inception, becoming a staple in the community with its commitment to quality and tradition. Every pizza is crafted with a careful blend of fresh ingredients and seasoned techniques that honor the city’s rich Italian-American heritage. The owners prioritize neighborhood connections, evident in their family-oriented service and the inviting retro vibe that feels like stepping into a bygone era. Their signature pies, including the acclaimed New Haven Style and Square Grandma, showcase their dedication to authentic flavors rooted in local history.

Casano’s also specializes in catering, making it a versatile choice for neighborhood gatherings, events, or casual weekday dinners. The commitment to community extends beyond food—supporting local vendors and fostering a space where locals feel at home. Their vision is simple: serve excellent pizza with love, build friendships, and keep Rutherford’s culinary tradition alive.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayOpen
  • MondayOpen
  • TuesdayOpen
  • WednesdayOpen
  • ThursdayOpen
  • FridayOpen
  • SaturdayOpen

Casano's stands out with its diverse pizza offerings—from the classic New Haven style with a perfect thin crust to inventive options like the seafood-topped Pancetta Clam Round Pie. The restaurant caters to all dining preferences with dine-in, takeaway, and delivery services, ensuring you access their comfort food anytime. Home-style favorites like chicken parm stracciatella, meatballs, and hot subs complement their pizza menu, making it ideal for family dinners or solo dining. The casual, kid-friendly ambiance creates a welcoming environment, enhanced by free street parking and multiple payment options, including credit cards.

The weekly peak times—Saturday at 2 PM—are bustling, but early afternoons or late evenings offer quieter moments for a relaxed experience. Casano’s also provides catering, perfect for parties or corporate events—just give them a 24-hour heads-up.

Casano's Pizza Parlor

Casano's exterior exudes a welcoming neighborhood charm, with inviting signage and a cozy storefront perfect for casual visits. In good weather, take advantage of their special outdoor tray setup, where you can enjoy your hot pizza al fresco, soaking in Rutherford’s friendly neighborhood vibe. Inside, the ambiance transports you to the 1980s, with retro couches, vintage decor, and a nostalgic TV screen that completes the living room feel. The vibe is casual and cozy—ideal for families, friends, or solo diners craving comfort food in a relaxed setting.

The bustling energy during peak hours gives it a lively, community-oriented atmosphere, while quieter times allow for a laid-back dining experience that makes everyone feel at home. Casano’s isn’t just a pizza place; it’s a neighborhood hub filled with warmth and nostalgia.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

I placed my order online and came to pick it up. The front is a classic neighborhood pizza parlor. There was a few guys sitting out front who's stares made it know that outsiders aren't so welcome. I stepped inside the restaurant and that was a lot more welcoming. The dining area looks like grandma's living room in the 1980s. I loved the decor and the old school wooden phone booth with the payphone in it. I had the chicken parm stracceriatelli(fantastic!!!!!!) & I got the new haven pie with pepperoni which was great also. I ordered a side of grandma's meatballs, they were ok. 10 minutes or less from Meadowlands arena. Would definitely recommend and will go back soon!!!! Update Tried the chicken parm with tomato sauce and the one with vodka sauce, I liked the one with vodka sauce better. I do recommend you asking for a cup of vodka sauce to go so you can pour some on the chicken.

M
Matthew M.

As a NJ-native, this was the best chicken parm and pizza I've had! The atmosphere was also retro (couches, fridges, phone booth and more). They had an old TV playing Donnie Brasco which fit the theme:)

A
Andrea K.

From the very first bite, I knew this wasn’t just pizza—it was an experience. The crust was perfectly balanced: crisp on the outside, airy and chewy on the inside, with that subtle char only a real artisan oven can deliver. The sauce? Bright, tangy, and bursting with the kind of fresh tomato flavor that instantly transports you to Italy. The cheese stretched beautifully with every slice, melting into the sauce like it was always meant to be there. And the toppings—each one felt intentional, not just thrown on. Fresh basil, fragrant olive oil, and just the right amount of seasoning tied everything together in absolute harmony. What makes it unforgettable is how it all came together: every bite layered with warmth, comfort, and flavor so deep that I found myself slowing down just to savor it longer. This wasn’t just food—it was pure joy. If I could bottle up the memory of this pizza, I would. Until then, I’ll be dreaming about it.

L
La V.

This place was recommended by a friend and it did not dissapoint! The pizza was excellent. The environment was super cute and comfy and the staff and their family (they were celebrating a birthday) were all so incredibly kind and inviting. They even shared the family birthday cake with us. If we lived in the area this would DEFINITELY be our new one and only go to for a pie. Wish I could give 10 stars.

J
Jadessa S.

Chicken Parm is very good. Big enough to it comes in a Pizza Box. The set up inside is pretty cool. Definitely support this establishment.

E
Edgar M.

Pies only, take out only. Inside is decorated like somebody's basement from the 80s. Have not ever seen a pizza shop with employees this young working so efficiently. Seems like they are providing some summer jobs to the community! I tried the New Haven pie and it was great. I'd come back to try more, seems like the vodka sauce pies are also popular.

J
JK A.